Friday, November 1, 2013

The CW Goes Medieval and That Rip in the Fabric of Time Thing Happens


Is this the worst thing to happen to television ever? I'll save you the trouble of thinking about it; yes it very much is. Why, god, why is it so hard for people in television to come together and make a good, accessible, medieval show that can also be available on Hulu or Netflix? Why? Game of Thrones, thank you; from the bottom of my heart you truly do make the world a better place, but for the love of corsets and man tights why can't I have something close to that level of period entertainment year round?

And who, exactly, was clamoring for a show about Mary, Queen of Scots to be made and marketed specifically for the tween audience? I mean, they don't know who this person is. They have no reference point; their knowledge of pop culture (formerly known as "history") doesn't even predate the first go around of Brittany Spears. I dare you to ask an average twelve-year-old girl how many wives Henry VIII had. In fact, simply ask them to identify a picture of him; you'll get the same blank stare.

Twelve-year-old girls have no idea who this guy is.
I mean, what's the point here? Are we trying to make 16th Century British Royals "cool" for the kids? Trying to slip in a little history lesson between Facebook updates and Googling pictures of...of...Bieber (Justin Bieber is still popular, right)? And if this is some weird attempt to teach something, then you're really missing the target on that one guys. I mean, look:


What is that supposed to be? I am no expert on textiles of Medieval history, but I suspect that is not a commonly occurring pattern in the 16th Century. Or even an uncommonly occurring pattern. I mean, what is that?

I nit-pick. But here's the thing: were the show actually good (decent script, good acting, a basic plot that goes beyond the predictable love triangle and the almost painful, clumsy attempt to introduce a supernatural component), I wouldn't care about the clothes. I wouldn't give two shades of grey about the historical accuracy. I just want a show that takes place in Medieval England Europe, the Isles, anywhere! And that doesn't suck. 

And just for the kids, this is Mary, Queen of Scots:

Really bad taste in men, as the story goes.
   






No comments: